What is gained or
lost by having the film version being narrated in the third person point of
view, instead of the Scout’s first person point of view in the book?
Third person and first person narration are very different
in he movie and the book. With the third person view, you can see everything
that is going on. The story is told from an outsider’s perspective. When Scout
is narrating in the beginning, a lot of things are missed because she is little
and does not understand most of the things that wen on in Maycomb. However,
there is something that is lost with a third person perspective. When Scout is
narrating, the reader can see how she grows up and how her thoughts develop. With
the third person narration, you do not get to see Scout’s thoughts, feelings,
and opinions about the events that go on.
Is the book better
than the movie?
As in many other cases, I think that the book is
way better than the movie. The film cuts out a lot of important scenes such as
the fire at miss Maudie’s house, Scout’s fight with Francis, and more scenes.
Also, characters are either portrayed differently of not shown. Another thing I
liked about the book that was not in the movie was how Scout narrated. I felt
that the movie was sort of rushed and just focused on the big scenes. One
thing, however, I thought the movie had that the book didn’t was emotion and
characters. You could see what characters looked like, how they talked, their
facial expressions, and more.